TV CSG

RESOLUTION

PUBLIC SESSION

BOARD OF DIRECTORS

CORPORATION FOR PUBLIC BROADCASTING

WASHINGTON, DC

Monday, December 11, 2023

 

unanimously

 

WHEREAS,

Under the provisions of the Public Broadcasting Act, CPB makes grants to eligible public television stations in a manner intended to provide for the needs and requirements of stations so that they may serve their local communities and audiences; and

 

WHEREAS,

The Community Service Grant (CSG) program is the primary mechanism for CPB to provide this financial support to local stations; and

 

WHEREAS,

CPB management has consulted with a panel of television station representatives regarding changes to CSG policy and invited and received comment directly from public television stations as part of this consultation process; and

 

WHEREAS,

CPB management has reviewed and endorses the panel’s recommendations that current policies be retained – including the base grant formula, methodology for reporting indirect administrative support, the minimum non-federal financial support eligibility requirement, and the second base grant policy for mergers – except as outlined below.

 

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT

The CPB Board of Directors hereby adopts CPB management’s recommendations for the following changes to television CSG policy.

Recommendation 1

 

Incentive Grant

Retain the tiering of non-federal financial support (NFFS) to calculate the incentive grant portion of the CSG with a change to Tier 3, applying the incentive rate of return (IRR) [1] to 80% instead of 95% of a grantees’ NFFS:

• Tier 1: Apply the IRR to 100% of a grantee’s NFFS for each dollar up to $3 million.
• Tier 2: Apply the IRR to 92.5% of a grantee’s NFFS for each dollar over $3 million but less than $20 million.
• Tier 3: Apply the IRR to 80% of a grantee’s NFFS for each dollar of $20 million or more.

 

Recommendation 2

 

Incentive Grant

Calculate the incentive grants of grantees that report NFFS of $35 million or more by using a five-year average NFFS. Then, tier the average NFFS per CPB policy.

Discontinue the current year-over-year growth limit on NFFS and options for grantees reporting more than $35 million in NFFS to make allocations of NFFS into future years.   

 

Recommendation 3

 

Universal Service Support Grant

Increase the pool for the Universal Service Support Grant program from 2% of the CPB’s federal appropriation to 2.2%.

 

 

RESOLUTION
PUBLIC SESSION
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
CORPORATION FOR PUBLIC BROADCASTING
WASHINGTON, D.C.
Monday, June 28, 2021

unanimously

WHEREAS,

Following discussions with the 2019 Television Community Service Grant (CSG) Policy Review panel, CPB commissioned research regarding the optimal period of time that television Community Service Grant (CSG) recipients that have merged should continue to receive the base grants that would have been provided to each of the grantees before the merger; and

WHEREAS,

CPB engaged research firm Pacey Economics, Inc, and has considered the research findings; and

WHEREAS,

Based on those research findings, CPB management seeks authorization to modify TV CSG policy to set the number of years a second base grant be provided at pre-merger levels to merged television entities to four years. 

THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED,

The CPB Board of Directors approves modifying TV CSG policy to set the number of years that CPB provides merging television CSG grantees with a second CSG base grant at pre-merger levels to four years. 

RESOLUTION
PUBLIC SESSION
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
CORPORATION FOR PUBLIC BROADCASTING
WASHINGTON, D.C.
June 28, 2021

unanimously

WHEREAS,

In September 2019, the CPB Board approved TV Community Service Grant (CSG) policy changes that included the establishment of a $1 million Healthy Network Initiative to begin October 1, 2020, to support eligible grantees that strategically develop and use data to more effectively understand, engage, and serve their audiences more effectively.

WHEREAS,

Since that time, COVID-19 created unprecedented economic disruption across the
nation, challenging public television stations’ ability to maintain local programming
and services.

WHEREAS,

On May 5, 2020, the Board approved Management’s recommendation to postpone the launch of this initiative so that public television stations could focus on addressing their communities’ intensified educational, health and safety, and public information needs during the COVID-19 crisis.

WHEREAS,

This period of financial uncertainty and intensified provision of services continues.

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT

The CPB Board of Directors hereby adopts CPB management’s recommendation to postpone the launch of the TV CSG Healthy Network Initiative from FY 2022 to
FY 2023; and retain for distribution through the television CSG pool the $1 million
that would have been allocated to the initiative in FY 2022. 

RESOLUTION
PUBLIC SESSION
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
CORPORATION FOR PUBLIC BROADCASTING
WASHINGTON, D.C.
Wednesday, October 14, 2020

unanimously

WHEREAS,

The CPB Board of Directors approved policy on August 6, 2007, allowing a merged entity of two television Community Service Grant (CSG) grantees to receive for a minimum of four years the base grant funds that would have been provided to each of the grantees before the merger; and

WHEREAS,

The CPB Board of Directors resolved on September 23, 2019, to leave the current CSG policy regarding base grants for merged television entities in place for a one-year period and directed CPB management to research and quantify the optimal amount of time that merged entities need to continue receiving base grants at a pre-merger level, and report back to the CPB Board with its findings and recommendations; and

WHEREAS,

CPB staff requires additional time to complete its research and expects to develop recommendations for the Board to consider in Fall 2021.

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT

The CPB Board of Directors approves retaining the current television base grants policy pending completion of research and presentation to the CPB Board of recommendations for the optimal amount of time for merged entities to continue receiving base grants at a pre-merger level.

RESOLUTION
PUBLIC SESSION
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
CORPORATION FOR PUBLIC BROADCASTING
WASHINGTON, D.C.
May 5, 2020

(7 in favor; 1 absent)

WHEREAS,

In September 2019, the CPB Board approved TV Community Service Grant policy changes that included the establishment of a $1 million Healthy Network Initiative to begin October 1, 2020, to support eligible grantees that strategically develop and use data to more effectively understand, engage, and serve their audiences.

WHEREAS,

Since that time, COVID-19 has created unprecedented economic disruption across the nation, challenging public television stations’ ability to maintain local programming and services.

WHEREAS,

Public television stations have incurred additional costs to meet their communities’ intensified educational, health and safety, and public information needs as a result of the COVID-19 crisis.

WHEREAS,

CPB Management, with the endorsement of the 2019 Television Community Service Grant panel of station representatives that originally recommended the Healthy Network Initiative, recommends delaying implementation of the new Healthy Network Initiative to FY 2022.

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT

The CPB Board of Directors hereby adopts CPB management’s recommendation to postpone the launch of the CSG Healthy Network Initiative from FY 2021 to FY 2022; and distribute as unrestricted funds through the general CSG pool the $1 million that would have been allocated to the initiative in FY 2021.  

RESOLUTION

PUBLIC SESSION

BOARD OF DIRECTORS

CORPORATION FOR PUBLIC BROADCASTING

WASHINGTON, D.C.

Monday, September 23, 2019

unanimously

 

WHEREAS,

Under the provisions of the Public Broadcasting Act, CPB makes grants to eligible public television stations in a manner intended to provide for the needs and requirements of stations so that they may serve their local communities and audiences; and

WHEREAS,

The Community Service Grant (CSG) program is the primary mechanism for CPB to provide this financial support to local stations; and

WHEREAS,

CPB management has consulted with a panel of television station representatives regarding changes to CSG policy and invited and received comment directly from public television stations as part of this consultation process; and

WHEREAS,

The panel of station representatives has made a series of recommendations to CPB management, which have been reviewed by management, shared with the public television system for further comment, and significantly informed management’s recommendations to the CPB Board.

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT

The CPB Board of Directors hereby adopts CPB management’s recommendations for changes to television CSG policy as outlined in the attached.

Recommendation 1

Increase the base grant by calculating it as 0.12% of CPB’s federal appropriation.  

Recommendation 2

Implement tiering of Non-Federal Financial Support (NFFS) to calculate the incentive grant portion of the CSG:

• Apply the incentive rate of return (IRR) to 100% of a grantee’s NFFS for each dollar up to $3 million.
• Apply the IRR to 92.5% of a grantee’s NFFS for each dollar over $3 million but less than $20 million.
• Apply the IRR to 95% of a grantee’s NFFS for each dollar of $20 million or more.

Recommendation 3

Limit future NFFS growth disparity by adding three incentive grant calculation mechanisms for grantees reporting NFFS of $20 million or more:   

1. Hold the grantee’s year-over-year NFFS increase to a percentage no greater than the system’s average year-over-year NFFS increase;
2. Where the grantee has a year-over-year increase, but the public television system does not, calculate its grant by using an amount that does not exceed the NFFS used to calculate its prior year’s grant;
3. Allow large grantees, whose NFFS can fluctuate considerably, to carry forward NFFS funds over multiple years to smooth their NFFS growth over time. The allocation of NFFS earned in the first year – but not entirely used to calculate their first-year grant – can count towards their NFFS totals for the following year (i.e., a two-year allocation) or the following two years (i.e., a three-year allocation).

Recommendation 4

Allow grantees to meet the $800,000 minimum NFFS eligibility requirement with either a three-year average NFFS of at least $800,000 (computed on the three most recent years of NFFS) or a current year NFFS of at least $800,000.If a grantee does not meet the $800,000 minimum but is the primary or sole public television service provider for its coverage area population, CPB will assess its sustainability and ability to provide a viable, sustainable service. If CPB determines that a grantee satisfies these criteria, it will be eligible for a CSG during the applicable grant period. Grantees that do not meet the NFFS minimum and do not satisfy the alternative criteria will become ineligible for a CSG and be permanently removed from the CSG program.

Recommendation 5

Institute a new method for reporting indirect administrative support (IAS) as NFFS:

1. Derive a rate by dividing the licensee’s indirect costs by its direct costs;
2. Apply the rate to a base amount consisting of the station’s net direct expenses (add physical plant support, if applicable, computed using CPB’s current instructions and subtract payments made by the station to its licensee for direct services).

Beginning with fiscal year 2020 annual financial reporting to CPB, grantees submitting an annual financial report (AFR) to CPB must use this method to report IAS as NFFS. Two exceptions would be provided: (1) State grantees, as approved by CPB, that do not have access to a sufficiently discrete financial statement may use a grantee-developed method; (2) Grantees that submit financial summary report (FSRs) will use a grantee-developed method. For stations that experience a significant reduction in IAS as a result of this policy change, CPB will allow for a phasing-in of the new method.

Recommendation 6

Leave the current policy regarding base grants for merged entities in place for a one-year period. Direct CPB management to research and quantify the optimal amount of time that merged entities need to continue receiving base grants at a pre-merger level, and report back to the CPB Board with its findings and recommendations.

Recommendation 7

Update the Healthy Network Initiative grant program to provide funds to eligible grantees that have strategically improved their use of their station’s data to better serve their audiences and to gain operational efficiencies. Annually fund the grant program with $1 million. Sunset the current Healthy Network Initiative programs by the end of fiscal year 2020. Return unused funds to the incentive grant pool. To qualify for the proposed new Healthy Network Initiative grant, CPB would require a grantee to complete a qualifying station data audit and implement at least two of the audit’s strategic data improvement recommendations, such as  expanding capacity for data collection, storage, and analysis; the acquisition and deployment of new data software systems; and the integration of data base systems to create efficiencies.